i am shure astaro team reads all posts, but i think they have not time to answer all posts. they invest the answer time in develop [;)]
Astaro-Report-Manager is an new feature to do a central reporting for asl-firewalls, e.g. you have to administrate a lot of, you can central see what happens. also you can correlate you data.
i think one of the main problem is that there are to many diferent hardware configurations out there - what about the apliances? do they have the same issues? i can't understand that my system is down more times a day for about 2 minutes and others aren't.
[ QUOTE ] To answer all the questions in this UBB by an astaro employee would need tons of time and menpower.
[/ QUOTE ] It's painfully obvious Astaro is not spending ANY time on this board to answer even the most important questions
If they don't want to be expected to post reply's to our problems and known bugs, then Astaro should not post here at all. If you do it a little then more is going to be expected. It's pretty obvious by Astaro's lack of participation here the past couple of weeks, that they have basically decided on the "hands off" approach! From what I can see, there have been only a handfull of Astaro posts in the last two weeks. I'd like to think that means they are working on the bugs. But then again they just came out with 5.025, which as we know is more about another new feature than anything else. So I'm not holding my breath about them spending more time on the bugs! [:(]
They've got to know that all this bad press on this board does not boad well for thier business, especially with regards to potential customers. Not only that but some of the best advertisement they can have is by the customers themselves. I have a feeling Astaro recommendations won't come as easily from current users at this point and time! And if it does it will probably come with a word of caution!
yep,many matter was dropped,but to tell the truth..you are wrong.,this because you make a noise without fondation..
I've make moderator in position to know the existence of this tread..
what "noise" are you referring to? Some of us know Astaro is busy right now and are voicing our concerns. Some may post out of sheer frustration. Plus i am sure the moderators already know of this thread.....Simply saying"you are making noise without a foundation" is exactly what you just did..this is not an argument just trying to belittle somebody.
[ QUOTE ] yep,many matter was dropped,but to tell the truth..you are wrong.,this because you make a noise without fondation.. I've make moderator in position to know the existence of this tread..
if u dont like this product,just dont use it.
Regards lin
[/ QUOTE ]
sit back and relax most of the users here are old asl irons - so i think that you're not really in the position to say kinda stuff, but hey you're the man [;)]
people draw conclusions based on the information they have.
As it stands there are three key facts:
Astaro make very little information available via this forum. Astaro has identified bugs in the firewall. Astaro are releasing new features in favour of fixes.
No matter how much you debate it these three facts are true.
In my opinion two things make this thread so popular.
Lack of information via this forum from Astaro and the simple undeniable fact of anyone who is interested in security (e.g. all here) that security devices and software should not have identified bugs with no impending solution.
Cap this of with users waiting eagerly for bug fix patches to fix the problems they "personally" are having and it is a recipe for bad relations.
In my opinion Astaro should:
Start a public bug tracker Dedicate some man power to these forums Release bug fixes until we have at least one stable V5 release
and then the prolem goes away.
If this is not possible then do what all big linux projects do... have a stable and devleopment branch.
At the end of the day it is lack of information that has caused this (which is one of many) threads.
I've been following this thread in silence, biting my tongue. But enough is enough, I've got to say something, and just let the chips fall where they may:
The beating up on Astaro in this thread (and some others) is unhelpful. If some of you think Astaro has issues, go use some of the other firewalls on the market -- none of them are perfect. There isn't a single piece of software or an operating system that doesn't have bugs that need fixing, and most companies just leave the bugs in and hope the users will put up with them. It seems to me that Astaro goes out of their way to make ASL the best it can be -- and they're doing a damn good job. Just go to the ICSA website and compare Astaro against all the other firewalls in the 4.0 criteria certified list -- most of them are dysfunctional toys compared to Astaro. There is NO DOUBT that ASL has some bugs that need fixing, but there is also no doubt that Astaro developers are chewing their fingers down to the knuckles and burning the midnight oil to get it right.
I apologize if my comments offended any individual -- I'm speaking to this whole thread in general.
I'm with OfficeDefender, You're getting about a million times more than you paid for. If you're a commercial client, use the support you're paying for. These forums are for FREE support for the FREE product you're using. Would you apply a windows service pack before seeing what other problems it creates. That the risk us "early adopters" run for being on the edge. If you're so offended that Astaro doesn't pay attention to this forum the way you think they should, try Smoothwall and Dick Morrell's attitude. We'll see you back here REAL soon.
OfficeDefender, I fully understand and agree with you in many ways but I have to say that releasing a new feature prior to a bug fixes was not a great idea.
Releasing new features before bug fixes may be Astaros policy but I do not agree with it.
I also agree that no piece of software does not have bugs.
But i reiterate my point, the ONLY REAL problem with Astaro is lack of information causing legitimate paying users to make assumptions that may ultimately be wrong.
As for Smoothwall do even go there... I too have been on the end of that terrible terrible attitude.
OfficeDefender, I fully understand and agree with you in many ways but I have to say that releasing a new feature prior to a bug fixes was not a great idea.
Releasing new features before bug fixes may be Astaros policy but I do not agree with it.
I also agree that no piece of software does not have bugs.
But i reiterate my point, the ONLY REAL problem with Astaro is lack of information causing legitimate paying users to make assumptions that may ultimately be wrong.
As for Smoothwall do even go there... I too have been on the end of that terrible terrible attitude.
[ QUOTE ] OfficeDefender, I fully understand and agree with you in many ways but I have to say that releasing a new feature prior to a bug fixes was not a great idea.
Releasing new features before bug fixes may be Astaros policy but I do not agree with it.
[/ QUOTE ]
There is a SERIOUS misunderstanding on this board as to how this all works, I hope I can correct it. Astaro, like most software vendors, runs on a roadmap. For example, when they released version 5 they had already mapped out a rough release schedule for features that didn't make it in the first cut. They know what they expect version 6 to be and they are working their way along a roadmap to get to that level. *Simultaneously*, they have developers working on bug fixes and releasing them as fast as possible after going through a QA process. THE RELEASE OF THE NEW FEATURE IN 5.025 IS NOT, I REPEAT, NOT AN INDICATION THAT ASTARO ISN'T WORKING ON FIXING EXISTING ISSUES!! You folks are reading way, way too much into this.
